“Gone But Not Forgotten: Buffalo Bird Woman Laments the Death of Indian Culture

       In this excerpt from her 1921 as-told-to memoirs, Hidatsa tribe member Buffalo Bird woman recalls better days before the arrival of an overbearing white Christian culture.

         I am an old woman now. The buffaloes and black-tail deer are gone, and our Indian ways are almost gone. Sometimes I find it hard to believe that I ever lived them.

           My little son grew up in the white man’s school. He can read books, and he owns cattle and has a farm. He is a leader among our Hidatsa people, helping teach them to follow the white man’s road.

       He is kind to me. We no longer live in an earth lodge, but in a house with chimneys; and my son’s wife cooks by a stove. But for me, I cannot forget our old ways. Often in summer I rise at daybreak and steal out to the cornfields; and as I hoe the corn I sing to it, as we did when I was young. No one cares for our corn songs now.

       Sometimes at evening I sit, looking out on the big Missouri. The sun sets, and dusk steals over the water. In the shadows I seem again to see our Indian village, with smoke curling upward from the earth lodges; and in the river’s roar I hear the yells of the warriors, the laughter of little children as of old. It is but an old woman’s dream. Again I see but shadows and hear only the roar of the river; and tears come into my eyes. Our Indian life, I know, is gone forever.

From “Waheenee: An Indian Girl’s Story Told by Herself to Gilbert L. Wilson,” North Dakota History: Journal of the Northern Plains, vol. 38, nos. 1 & 2 (Winter/Spring 1971). Reprinted in Peter Nabokov, ed., Native American Testimony (New York: Viking, 1991), 182.

 

Read the following documents, comparing the conception and values placed on wilderness. Keep this in mind while you read the chapter in Loewen, Lies My Teacher Told Me, 254-270

Chief Luther Standing Bear Gives an Indian View of Wilderness, Recorded in 1933

 

“We did not think of the great open plains, the beautiful rolling hills, and winding streams with tangled growth, as ‘wild’. Only to the white man was nature a ‘wilderness’ and only to him was the land ‘infested’ with wild animals and ‘savage’ people. To us it was tame. Earth was bountiful and we were surrounded with the blessings of the Great Mystery. Not until the hairy man from the east came and with brutal frenzy heaped injustices upon us and the families we loved was it ‘wild’ for us. When the very animals of the forest began fleeing from his approach, then it was that for us the ‘Wild West’ began.”

Plenty-Coups Mourns the Vanishing Buffalo, Recorded in 1950

(The buffalo was central to many of the tribes of west, it was a major food source, but also provided materials for clothes, shelter, and many of the cultural rituals)

    “Our country is the most beautiful of all. Its rivers and plains, its mountains and timber lands, where there was always plenty of meat and berries, attracted other tribes, and they wished to possess it for their own.

     To keep peace our chiefs sent out clans to the north, east, south and west. They were to tell any who wished to come into our country that they were welcome. They were told to say, “you may hunt and gather berries and plums in our country, but when you have all you can carry you must go back to your own lands. If you do this all will be well. But if you remain overlong, we will warn you to depart. If you are foolish and do not listen, your horses will be stolen. And if even this does not start you homeward, we will attack you and drive you out.

     The country belonging to the Crows was not only beautiful, but it was the very heart of the buffalo range of the Northwest. It embraced endless plains, high mountains and great rivers, fed by streams clear as crystal. No other section could compare, especially when it was untouched by white men.

    ….When the buffalo went away the hearts of my people fell to the ground, and they could not lift them up again. After this nothing happened. There was little singing anywhere.”

 

Quiet Compromise: Goodbird Takes Up the Ways of the White Man

Edward Goodbird, a Hidatsa, recounts the subtle ways in which Indians managed to retain small aspects of their culture in the face of white efforts to exorcise Native-American customs and beliefs.

 

        The time came when we had to forsake our village at Like-a-fish-hook Bend, for the government wanted the Indians to become farmers. “ You should take allotments,” our agent would say. “ The big game is being killed off, and you must plant bigger fields or starve. The government will give you plows and cattle.”

All knew that the agent’s words were true, and little by little our village was broken up. In the summer of my sixteenth year nearly a third of my tribe left to take up allotments.

            We had plenty of land; our reservation was twice the size of Rhode Island, and our united tribes, with the Rees who joined us, were less than thirteen hundred souls. Most of the Indians chose allotments along the Missouri, where the soil was good and drinking water easy to get.  Unallotted lands were to be sold and the money given to the three tribes.

                Forty miles above our village, the Missouri makes a wide bend around a point called Independence Hill, and here my father and several of his relatives chose their allotments. The bend enclosed a wide strip of meadow land, offering hay for our horses. The soil along the river was rich and in the bottom stood a thick growth of timber.

        My father left the village, with my mother and me, in June. He had a wagon, given him by the agent; this he unbolted and took over the river piece by piece, in a bull boat; our horses swam.

          We camped at Independence in a tepee, while we busied ourselves building a cabin. My father cut the logs; they were notched at the ends, to lock into one another at the corners. A heavier log, a foot in thickness, made the ridge pole. The roof was of willows and grass, covered with sods. Cracks between the logs were plastered with clay, mixed with short grass. The floor was of earth, but we had a stove.  We were a month putting up our cabin.

       Though my father’s coming to Independence was step toward civilization, it had one ill effect: it removed me from the good influences of the mission school, so that for a time I fell back into Indian ways. Winter, also, was not far off; the season was too late for us to plant corn, and the rations issued to us every two weeks rarely lasted more than two or three days. To keep our family in meat, I turned hunter.

         There were no buffaloes on the reservation, but blacktailed deer were plentiful, and in the hills were a good many antelopes. I had a Winchester rifle, a 40.60 caliber, and I was a good shot.

             To hunt deer, I arose before daylight and went to the woods along the Missouri. Deer feed much at night, and as evening came on, they would leave the thick underbrush by the river and go into the hills to browse on the rich prairie grasses.

 

 

An Editor Bids Good Riddance to Buffalo, 1979

From The Daily Chronicle, Centralia-Chehalis, Washington, September 10, 1979

     Gone are the millions of American buffalo. Their wanton slaughter brought temporary profit and sport. But their departure opened the North American continent for human development.

     The bison known as the plains buffalo in America well could serve as a national symbol for the concept that human progress requires environmental alterations, whether in mining ore, building factories, plowing ground or controlling wild beasts. . .

      Domestic animals bred to highest qualities of dinner-plate tastes and cost-efficiency graze in peace across America without fear of attack from stampeding buffalo. .

      Few should weep over buffalo. America never would have blossomed to its current status in world leadership unless buffalo were removed from the land.

      As the white civilization pushed westward from the Allegheny Mountains, vast herds of buffalo were slaughtered purposely to permit farms to be created, railroads to be built, housewives to pluck carrots without being trampled. .. The beasts existed for private enterprise to consume, to clear the land for superior breeds, crops, cities, human growth and progress.

      With some 60 million of the awesome beasts virtually wiped from the face of North America, human ingenuity and hard work rapidly converted the Great Plains and rolling hills into modern miracles of agricultural production, thriving cities, hearty commerce and vigorous Americans.